Monday, 01 March 2010

Skating With the Triumphant Plebeians

By Nina Kouprianova
  • Comments
  • Print
  • Share/Bookmark
Skating With the Triumphant Plebeians Evgeniy Plyushchenko

During the Cold War, the world of sports was one of the main arenas used to demonstrate ideological superiority on both sides of the Iron Curtain. Growing up in Moscow at the tail end of the Soviet era, I remember that Olympic-level coaches visited elementary schools around the country and hand-picked children they deemed suitable for international competitions.

They often chose me for my athletic body type. The selection process was thorough: once the coaches determined that I were likely to grow beyond 5 feet tall, for example, based on my parents' genetics, they rejected me for disciplines like gymnastics and diving. But, as a result of Soviet athletic zeal -- combined with my mother's emphasis on education and fitness -- I got to participate in a variety of sports: swimming, tennis, badminton, cross country skiing, table tennis (!), and figure skating, not to mention playing soccer and the like with the neighbourhood kids. And, while neither my family, nor I had an interest in sports beyond health benefits, I still have fond memories of this part of my childhood.


The latter is one of the reasons why I have a bit of an amateur interest in contemporary figure skating. So much so, that I've already once defended my Russian compatriots in this discipline in a (heavily edited) letter to Time magazine years ago.

Needless to say, I was shocked by the 2010 Olympic men’s figure skating results and disappointed by the ice dancing competition. In the former event, three-time world champion and 2006 Olympic champion Evgeniy Plyushchenko’s (Rus) risk-taking performance lost the gold to Evan Lysacek’s (U.S.) painfully average routine. In the latter discipline, judges, the media, and the public were more interested in Oksana Domnina’s and Maksim Shabalin’s (Rus) “offensive” costumes than their skill level. If this is the status quo in the world of ice skating, then Western cultural decline is worse than I imagined.

Sports are supposed to progress: athletes break records in timed events and take greater risks in judged competitions. Not anymore. Canadian skating legend Elvis Stojko equated Lysacek’s gold medal with the murder of figure skating:

Sorry, Evan Lysacek. You’re a great skater and all. But that wasn’t Olympic champion material. In Thursday night’s men’s free skate, Lysacek skated slow and his jumps weren’t close to the technical ability of defending Olympic champion Evgeni Plushenko. [...] ...the judges’ scoring was ridiculous. Because of it, the sport took a step backward. Brian Boitano did the same thing, technically, in 1988. There are junior skaters who can skate that same program."

My own opinion regarding the Russian figure skater is not a result of zealous patriotism. Admittedly, this year Russian athletes did not perform up to par in a number of their usual strong suits, like biathlon or cross-country skiing. Northern Europeans were simply stronger, faster, better. But, Russians outdid themselves in a number of unexpected venues (women’s parallel snowboard slalom, for instance). I can only hope that my compatriots push themselves harder on the home front at Sochi-2014, but I will cheer for them, no matter what.

No, Plyushchenko's silver was not a result of a massive anti-Russian conspiracy, though much of the Western media has been noticeably gloating since. Rather, the new judging standards in this discipline have become a systemic affirmation of mediocrity. Lysacek's well performed routine without truly difficult acrobatics was a solid average, no more. Elvis Stojko argued that:

The naysayers believe the quadruple does not need to be included to succeed at these Olympics [...] However, this is a sport where the element of risk is needed. Boring is the program without the challenge."

More important, the Winter Olympic Games are a competition, which, by and large, exhibits European prowess (with due credit given to East Asians). As such, it has been one of the last venues in which Europe’s culture hasn’t been continuously clobbered over the head by the establishment.

Up until now, that is.

In the past year, the world of ice dancing has been more concerned with being at the cutting edge of sensitivity training than technical skills. Russian pair Oksana Domnina and Maksim Shabalin may be world champions in this discipline. Yet, they are better known for “offending” aboriginals worldwide -- from Australia to Canada -- for wearing elaborate, patterned body suits. In fact, they were not only pressured to tone down their costumes for the 2010 Winter Games, but also -- to perform an official, publicized gift exchange with Canada’s aboriginal community. However, the God of Political Correctness is the most wrathful deity on contemporary Olympus and, quite frankly, does not grant atonement. Or gold medals.

But, should we really be surprised? In an environment, where the Hollywood Assembly Line churns out expensive, boring remakes and sequels, why shouldn't a polished, uninteresting 20-year old figure skating remake of a routine be rewarded? In a society where nurses spend more time in Tolerance Camp than a chemistry lab, why should we bother with the ice dancers’ physical training?

Contemporary North American culture not only caters to, but also -- promotes the lowest common denominator through that winning combination of bread and circuses. (Though, unlike the late Roman plebes, we are a whole lot more emotionally delicate. So, I guess, there’s been some progress after all!) Women, who get famous through deliberately leaked home-made porn, are designated "fashion icons". Barely literate rappers are called great "artists". And, why pick on rappers, when college graduates everywhere seriously lack grammar, syntax, and spelling skills? Basic historic facts that were taken for granted just a few decades ago -- like, when the Mona Lisa was painted -- are no longer common knowledge. Even when it comes to the modern Olympic tradition specifically, there has been a gradual decline of the official musical themes chosen over the years.

We all know this. We know all of this. And, because we know it, we deserve it. But, let us continue toning down our costumes and let us forget the quadruple jump altogether. Carry on.

Article Info

Nina Kouprianova

Nina Kouprianova

Nina grew up a subway ride away from the Kremlin, and is still a proud Muscovite at heart. A PhD candidate by day, a graphic designer by night, a Japanophile and a rocker, she is a jack of all trades and master of…some!

AltRight Information Service

Sign up to receive event invitations, updates, and letters from the editor!

Most Popular

NPI Conference Videos
Winglord
Arktos Christmas Sale
Alain de Benoist: Beyond Human Rights (Softcover)
Join Arktos on Facebook
The Owls of Afrasiab by Lars Holger Holm
The Wasp Question by Andrew Fraser
The Node by Tito Perdue
Tito Perdue
The Doctor and the Heretic and Other Stories by Andy Nowicki